Answer to: Can we publish a paper on the implementation of an already published paper (implemented on a different platform)?

In my opinion, if its the sole contribution or novelty of the paper you are planning to publish, then it do not think so it is sufficient enough to publish.

You may make a technical report on it and upload in arXiv. But, if you want to publish, then I think you have to some more analysis and perform experiments to make the novelty of the paper significant.

Another possible direction may be to implement a set of related papers, possibly benchmark models on common datasets and compare their results and provide inferences. Some conferences like ECIR (European Conference on Information Retrieval) have started a “Reproducibility Track” specifically for such studies.

ECIR also strongly encourages the submission of reproducibility papers that repeat and analyze prior work. In particular we solicit classical reproducibility papers, which replicate prior experiments and show how, why, and when the methods work (or not), along with two other types of reproducibility papers: generalizability papers, that focus on assessing how well technology performs in new contexts (e.g., different time, location, access device, task), and predictability papers, that focus on developing theory and methods that assess and evaluate how generalizable methods are and whether they will work in other contexts.

ECIR website, Call for papers section

This is my answer on Quora to the question “Can we publish a paper on the implementation of an already published paper (implemented on a different platform)?

Please comment below if you would like to add something.

roysoumya

Hello everyone. I am Soumyadeep. I have been working on Machine learning projects for the last 4 years. I am now pursuing Ph.D. in Computer Science Department at IIT Kharagpur. I recently completed M.S (Research) from the same department in November, 2019. My research interests involve applying Machine Learning, NLP and Deep Learning to solve Online Reputation Monitoring and Consumer Health Search problems.

Leave a Reply